Some places feel like they were plucked straight out of a fairytale. Mackinac Island? It’s the whole storybook. Horse-drawn carriages instead of Ubers, pastel-painted Victorian homes, and the scent of lilacs and fresh fudge drifting through cobblestone-lined streets. It’s hard not to slow down, breathe a little deeper, and soak in every second of the nostalgic charm.
We made the day trip during our Traverse City getaway and left feeling like we’d just stepped out of a time machine. If you’re thinking about spending a day on Mackinac Island, here’s exactly how to make it count.
Getting to Mackinac Island:
You’ll want to head north from Traverse City to Mackinaw City (about 3 hours), where you can catch the Shepler’s Ferry or Star Line Ferry across the water. Both offer quick, scenic rides about 15–20 minutes with open-air top decks for soaking in that fresh Michigan breeze and a killer view of the iconic Mackinac Bridge.
Local Tip: Book your ferry tickets ahead of time, especially in peak summer. Opt for early morning to maximize your time on the island. Bonus: some ferries include a quick ride under the bridge!.
How to Get Around
Spoiler…no cars allowed. That’s part of the charm!
• On Foot — The downtown area is very walkable, especially for browsing shops or strolling by the harbor.
• Bike Rentals are everywhere. Rent one and ride the 8.2 mile loop around the entire island. It’s flat, scenic, and full of stop-worthy views.
• Horse-Drawn Carriages are a must for that storybook feel. You can book a guided tour or hop a public taxi (aka a carriage stop).
But real talk? Be prepared for the…aroma.
With horses as the main mode of transport, there’s an unavoidable downside…the smell. Especially in summer, the scent of horse poop hangs in the air and lines the streets. It’s part of the island’s charm-slash, reality check. You’ll find city workers doing their best to keep it clean, but there’s no escaping it completely. So bring comfy shoes and a bit of patience for the “natural perfume.”
Local Tip: Bring cash for tips and bike lock deposits. And wear comfy shoes…cobblestones are cute but unforgiving.
♥ This post contains some affiliate links. If you purchase something I’ve recommended, I’ll earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I appreciate your support and hope this guide helps you!
Things To Do on Mackinac Island
1. Bike Around the Island You’ll ride past rocky beaches, the glittering blue water of Lake Huron, forested trails, and famous natural rock formations like Arch Rock. Stop for a photo — it’s iconic for a reason.
2. Visit Fort Mackinac History buffs and view-seekers, this one’s for you. Perched high on a bluff, the 18th century fort has costumed interpreters, cannon demonstrations, and panoramic harbor views. Near Marquette Park.
3. Eat All the Fudge You can’t leave without trying at least one slab of the world-famous fudge. JoAnn’s Fudge and Murdick’s are two legendary stops. Don’t be shy about sampling!!
4. Stroll Through Downtown From cute boutiques to cozy bookstores and sweet flower shops, downtown Mackinac is the perfect place to wander. You’ll find souvenir charm
5. Admire the Grand Hotel Even if you’re not staying there (yet), you can still take in its splendor. The front porch is the longest in the world and pure Americana. There’s a small admission fee for non-guests, but it’s worth it for the views and historic vibes alone.
6. Explore the Butterfly House & Insect World Charming, educational, and kid-friendly. Located just off the main street. Look for the adorable garden path.
7. Picnic at Mission Point Pack your lunch or grab a sandwich from Doud’s Market, then find a grassy spot on the lawn of Mission Point. The views of the lake are the perfect backdrop
8. Visit the Mackinac Island Botanical Trail A hidden gem. Peaceful, scenic walking trails, educational signage, and wildflowers galore.
Where to Eat
Breakfast or Brunch:
• Watercolor Café (near Mission Point): tucked in an art gallery with fresh breakfast sandwiches and lake views.
• Chuckwagon: A local classic. diner-style, quick, and satisfying. Think cozy booths and great omelets.
Lunch with a View:
• The Pink Pony: Easily the island’s most popular bar and grill. Right on the water with a tropical meets Midwest vibe. Get the whitefish tacos or their signature rum runner.
• Millie’s on Main: Casual, pub style menu and great perch sandwiches. Centrally located near the ferry docks.
Sweet Treats:
• JoAnn’s Fudge or Murdick’s: Worth mentioning again. Enough said.
• Sadie’s Ice Cream Parlor (inside Grand Hotel): old-fashioned counter service with Mackinac Island fudge ice cream. Yes, it’s a thing.
♥ This post contains some affiliate links. If you purchase something I’ve recommended, I’ll earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I appreciate your support and hope this guide helps you!
Where to Stay (If You Were Staying the Night)
We didn’t stay overnight, but if we had, these would be top of our list based on what we saw and what we’ve since researched:
- The Grand Hotel Elegant, iconic, and unapologetically over-the-top. Open since 1887, it’s a full-on experience with dress codes at dinner and daily tea. The kind of place you go for an occasion or to create one.
- Hotel Iroquois Perched right on the edge of downtown with lush gardens and waterfront views, this boutique-style gem feels like a hidden retreat but steps from the action. Rooms are bright, timeless, and cozy. Have lunch or dinner at the Carriage House restaurant. Delicious with the best views.
- Island House Hotel Mackinac’s oldest operating hotel with a gorgeous front lawn, charming historic details, and killer views of the harbor. It’s walkable to downtown and a little quieter than the main strip.
Local Tip: If you’re doing an overnight, recommend to book 6–9 months in advance especially June through September. Shoulder seasons offer lower rates and fewer crowds.
When to Go
Spring (May–early June): The lilacs are in bloom, the air is crisp, and the island reawakens after winter. A perfect time for fewer crowds and all the charm.
Summer (June–August): Peak season. Expect sunshine, full ferry schedules, and everything open. It’s vibrant, festive, and worth the energy.
Fall (September–October): The leaves turn fiery, the temps cool off, and the crowds start to thin out. Gorgeous for bike rides and photo ops.
Winter: The island slows down a bit and is mostly closed to tourists. If you’re up for snowmobiling and solitude, it’s a whole different world but not ideal for first-timers.
What to Pack for a Day Trip
Before you head out to the Island, make sure you’re well prepared.
Packing wisely includes bringing items that will enhance your visit. You’ll want to capture the beauty of the island, protect yourself from the elements, and stay hydrated throughout your trip.
- Comfortable walking shoes – Cobblestones + bike rides = no time for blisters.
- Light jacket or layer – Even in summer, mornings on the ferry can be breezy.
- Sunscreen + sunglasses – There’s no escaping that lakefront glare.
- Small backpack or crossbody bag – Keep it hands-free for biking and fudge-sampling.
- Refillable water bottle – Hydrate between adventures (and fudge tastings).
- Cash for tips and small shops – Some spots still operate the old-school way.
- picnic blanket – Especially if you’re heading to Mission Point or the parks.
- Travel-size hand sanitizer or wipes – Between bike rentals, fudge fingers, and horse everything… trust me.
Making the Most of Your Mackinac Island Adventure
If you could do just one thing? Rent a bike, ride the full loop around the island, and let the breeze and beauty reset your soul a little. Mackinac Island isn’t about speed. It’s about slowing down, looking around, and letting the unexpected charm do its thing.
We came for the fudge and the ferry ride. We left wanting to stay longer next time, maybe even just one night in a room with a porch swing and a water view. Because sometimes the best travel surprises come in pastel, car-free packages with lilacs in bloom and no notifications.
Leave a Reply